Located on North Main Street, north of Chiapas Restaurant
The first recorded meeting of the Sugar Creek Baptists was November 2, 1799. In 1802, property was purchased from Aaron Nutt, and by 1803, a meeting house was erected on the west side of the cemetery. Early residents traveled to the church on trails, which were blazed through the wilderness from settlements five miles away. On July 4, 1807, the church trustees appointed Benjamin Robbins and Whitely Hatfield "to lay off a burial ground in proper manner." Additions to the cemetery continued until 1868, which extended the cemetery to its present boundaries. Many early settlers, including veterans of the Revolutionary and other wars, are interred there.
In 2020, members of Centerville-Washington History and community volunteers began a multi-year restoration project at the Sugar Creek Cemetery. Washington Township donated funds to the project, and in 2020, 86 volunteers spent a combined 1,376 hours cleaning 320 headstones. In 2021, 52 volunteers cleaned the remaining 125 headstones, and a professional company was hired to repair 83 broken headstones. In 2022, approximately 100 tilted headstones were repositioned by a professional company.